In a time when confidence in public institutions is often tested, the judiciary plays a critical role in maintaining stability, fairness, and trust. That was the central message shared by The Honorable S. Bernard Goodwyn, who served on the Virginia Supreme Court from 2007 until his retirement in 2026 and as Chief Justice from 2022 to 2026.
Drawing on nearly two decades of service on the Commonwealth’s highest court, Justice Goodwyn offered Rotary members an inside look at Virginia’s judicial system and the principles that guide it. A Harvard-educated attorney with a distinguished career in public service, he focused his remarks on the rule of law, the structure of Virginia’s courts, and the responsibilities of the Chief Justice.
Justice Goodwyn began by recognizing Rotary’s commitment to strengthening communities and advancing values that support the fair administration of justice.
At the heart of his presentation was the concept of the rule of law. Simply stated, it means that no one is above the law and no one is beneath its protection. The same rules apply to everyone, including elected officials and those in positions of authority. This principle serves as a cornerstone of democratic society, providing consistency, accountability, and protection of individual liberties.
Justice Goodwyn emphasized that courts provide a forum where disputes can be resolved according to established legal principles rather than political influence or public opinion. He said maintaining public trust in that process is among the judiciary’s most important responsibilities. While confidence in the courts has been built over generations, it can be lost quickly if citizens no longer believe the system is fair and impartial.
He also outlined the structure of Virginia’s court system. Cases typically begin in General District Courts or Juvenile and Domestic Relations Courts before moving, if appealed, to Circuit Courts, the Court of Appeals, and ultimately the Supreme Court of Virginia. As the state’s court of last resort, the Supreme Court reviews decisions made by lower courts to ensure laws are interpreted and applied consistently throughout the Commonwealth.
Beyond deciding cases, the Supreme Court serves as the administrative head of Virginia’s judicial branch. As Chief Justice, Goodwyn was responsible for helping shape the judiciary’s vision, improving access to justice, overseeing resources, and guiding long-term planning.
He concluded with a reminder that courts belong to the people, not the judges, and that an informed citizenry is essential to preserving the rule of law and the constitutional system that has served the nation for generations.
THE MEETING
President Dave Duncan presided over the meeting for the final time during his Rotary year. We thank Dave for his dedicated service and leadership to our club!
Tom Koller presented Suds & Buds checks to Norfolk Botanical Garden and Sarah Michelle Peterson Foundation. Each receives $22,233. Dave Duncan recognized Tom for his efforts, without which this wouldn’t have happened.
Tom Koller, Chris Barco and Ali Barnard from the Norfolk Botanical Garden, Dave Duncan
Tom Koller, Michelle Peterson and Amy Woods from the Sarah Michelle Peterson Foundation, Dave Duncan
GUESTS
Lynn Neumann, Hampton Roads Community Foundation
Mavis McKenley, Trust Officer with AMG
Damon DeSue, BDO Accounting
VOLUNTEER RECOGNITION
Marty Raiss, chair of the Volunteer Committee, thanked all members who participated in service projects throughout the year and recognized several Rotarians for their outstanding contributions.
"Gold Star" recognitions included:
Jim Tucker and Tom Ambler for attending the greatest number of service projects.
Hank Thompson as the club’s best "Johnny-on-the-Spot" volunteer, always ready to help when needed.
Eleanor Schoonover for her perseverance and dedication in helping Ross Woods successfully complete his post-doctoral work.
Sally Hartman for her efforts in writing the club’s district grant.
Pam Tubbs, John Ehalt, and Kelly Stefanko for their valuable behind-the-scenes work supporting club activities and initiatives.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Dave’s Farewell – this is his last meeting.
Dave recognized Jeff Ryder as the club’s newest Paul Harris Fellow
Dave announced today is Hank Thompson’s final meeting with us.
Don’t forget to sign up for committees!
June 24th – Companion Club Meeting, speaker is Kindra Green-Elizabeth River Trail
BIG POT RAFFLE! Thanks to Dr. Joy and Pam Tubbs for selling tickets all year long. Congratulations to Sigur Whitaker for winning the $1,412 big pot size!
